When I first started this business, I drank whiskey neat; not because I like it, but because I think it is. there was to enjoy. Purists like those found on online forums, in crowded bars, and quoted in whiskey books had all convinced me that real drinkers didn't need ice. Frankly, I was trying to fit in with the cool kids.
But as I delved deeper into the finest whiskey and began to discover its many nuances, I found myself increasingly gravitating towards a glass filled with a large chunk of ice, or “on the rocks” in bar parlance. And that changed everything.
When it comes down to how to drink whiskey the right way, it's all a matter of personal preference. But it turns out that ice can enhance your whiskey experience in surprising ways.
How Does Ice Change the Taste of Whiskey?
Ice dilutes the whiskey as it melts, but that's not necessarily a bad thing. For many whiskeys, a little dilution can bring out the flavors in unexpected and delightful ways.
I experienced this firsthand on a summer trip to Kentucky a few years ago. One sweltering afternoon, I was visiting a distillery known for its high-proof bourbons. The distiller presented me with a neat example of its flagship spirit, and it nearly knocked me out with its intensity.
He must have noticed my reaction because he quietly suggested adding an ice cube to my whiskey glass. What happened next was nothing short of revealing. The whiskey transformed, becoming smoother and more complex, creating layers of flavors I hadn't noticed before. It was a Eureka moment. Ice was not the enemy; it was a tool to unlock new flavor profiles.
Related: Put Your Calculator Aside. Here's How Many Shots Are There in a Shot of Liquor
Take a full-bodied bourbon like Booker's, for example, which has an ABV rate as high as 60 percent. Drinking it neat is an intense experience that can overwhelm even the most seasoned palate. But drop a large ice cube into the glass and the whiskey's fiery edges soften as it slowly melts. A completely new profile emerges; Notes of caramel, vanilla and dark fruit were previously masked by the warmth of the alcohol.
How Do Temperature and Dilution Affect Whiskey?
This isn't just anecdote; There's real science behind how ice enhances whiskey. When the temperature of whiskey is lowered, some volatile compounds (especially higher alcohols) become less detectable, allowing other flavors to come to the fore. This is especially important for whiskeys at the upper end of the ABV spectrum, where the alcohol can dominate and mute the finer notes.
Moreover, the dilution process releases congeners and oils that can intensify aromas and flavors. For this reason, many distillers recommend adding a drop or two of water to barrel-strength whiskeys. By placing the whiskey on the rocks, you prolong this process and provide a gradual dilution that allows you to experience how the whiskey develops in the glass.
Of course, not all ice is created equal. A giant, slow-melting cube is preferable to a handful of crushed ice, which will quickly over-dilute and dilute the whiskey. The goal is to chill and condition the whiskey, not overwhelm it.
There is also a cultural element to consider. Drinking whiskey neat can be intimidating to newcomers who may not yet appreciate whiskey in its undiluted form. For many people, the intensity of a neat whiskey (especially a peated Scotch or a high-proof bourbon) can be too much and completely distract them from the spirit. Whiskey on the rocks is more approachable and therefore more enjoyable for a wider audience.
Related: How to Make Clear Ice for Cocktails at Home
Is There a Proper Way to Drink Whiskey?
Whiskey is, at its core, meant to be enjoyed. Whether plain, iced or in a whiskey cocktail, it is a drink that must be savored. Ice allows experienced whiskey drinkers, whether novice or seasoned, to experiment and discover new facets of the spirit that you might not otherwise notice.
The whiskey world has no need for snobbery. Inclusion requires experimentation and enjoyment. Some of my best whiskey moments have been experienced on a warm summer evening with a few friends, watching the sun set while sipping Scotch or bourbon over ice. No pretense, no judgment; just the pure enjoyment of a good drink shared among friends.
So the next time someone tells you that the only way to enjoy whiskey is neat, feel free to nod politely and then pop a big cube into your glass. You'll be in good company and can enjoy your whiskey a little more.
Related: I've Tasted Hundreds of Whiskeys. This Classic Luxury Scotch Is the Best You Can Buy