Why Arthur Flack Doesn't Kill Sophie

One of Todd Phillips' biggest questions Joker Whether or not Arthur killed his neighbor Sophie was left to the audience. Of course, in Joker: Folie à Deux Sophie is revealed to be alive, which raises the question of why she didn't? 2019 year Joker It offered a fresh version of DC's most popular Batman villain. Not surprisingly, the film had a darker tone than many other comic book character based films. Part of the film's intrigue lies in its leave to the imagination, which answers a number of questions. Joker: Folie à Deux.

First Joker: Folie à Deux, One of the biggest questions is the fate of both Arthur's character and his neighbor Sophie (Zazie Beetz), who is believed by the audience to be in a relationship with him for a good portion of the film. With Arthur suffering from mental illness, one of the biggest twists in the story was when everything on screen was only revealed in Arthur's mind, including his romance with Sophie. When the illusion is broken, Sophie's reaction is terrifying. Arthur leaves and Sophie is never seen again.

Joker's Deleted Scene reveals that Arthur Fleck did not kill Sophie

After Todd Phillips himself spoke about it and the official script of the film was released online in 2019, it was confirmed that Arthur did not kill Sophie. Joker. Fortunately, his character was originally supposed to reappear in a deleted scene where he watches Arthur's deathly apparition Live with Murray Franklin. She and her daughter were written to react with horror as they watched the events of the episode and their aftermath on television.

From Joaquin-Phoenix-Joker-and-Arthur-Fleck-The-Joker-Franchise

What happened between Joker 1 and 2?

The timeline between Joker and Joker: Folie à Deux means that there were a lot of changes and inciting events that happened between the films.

Although there is no way for the audience to know that he survived just by watching the film, Joker: Folie à Deux revealing that he is still alive. Beetz reprized her role as Sophie in the cast Joker: Folie à Deuxand was one of the witnesses called to testify at Arthur Fleck's trial for the multiple murders he committed in the first film. He recounts what happened the night he entered Arthur's apartment.

Why Arthur Flack Doesn't Kill Sophie in Joker

Although he and his behavior are seriously disturbed throughout JokerArthur Fleck's multiple murders are not as random as they seem. In the violence he uses (which cannot be justified in any way), these are the attempts of the beaten man to refuse the ordinary life in society and even sickly account. Up to this point, his first three victims are drunken Wayne Enterprises employees who chase and beat the protagonist on the subway.

He later kills her in the hospital after learning the truth about her mother and their terrible past together. And while preparing for Murray's show, he kills his former co-worker Randall. Arthur takes pity on another former colleague, Gary, who was with Randall when he was killed and later comes to testify at Arthur's trial. Joker: Folie à Deux. disgusting though these patterns make “logical” sense in terms of Joker's evil protagonist.

Unlike many other people in her life, Sophie's behavior towards Arthur is never mean or wrong.

Also, Arthur sparing Gary, even verbally admitting that he did so because he was always nice to him, is the other half of why he lets Sophie live. He was nice to her in the elevator and even treated her with respect and offered to help her when she got to his apartment in a scary way. Unlike many people in his life, Sophie's behavior towards Arthur is never mean or wrong. For this simple reason, like Gary, Arthur allows his neighbor to live.

Why did Todd Phillips cut Sophie's scene in Joker?

Arthur Flack in Joker makeup looks at himself in the mirror

Leaving it out is an interesting creative choice Joker After an illusion-shattering interaction with Arthur in the living room, the scene confirms Sophie's survival. According to a 2019 article IGN“Phillips noted that he specifically cut Sophie's reaction moment because it violated the film's motif of always keeping it from Arthur's point of view. It would take Arthur away from the people he was interacting with for a moment and directly.”

Joker: Folie à Deux
sheds more light on what was actually real during the events of the first film.

This is very true: Joker's the story is the story of Arthur Fleck and his own subjective experienceshowever invalid and/or imagined they may be. Since its release, there has been controversy over what actually happened in the film. After all, Arthur's entire relationship with Sophie is a fantasy Joker can it seem objectively real or true? Of course, chasing that answer isn't the point of the piece – so it makes sense that Todd Phillips decided to cut the scene at the end that proves Arthur didn't kill Sophie.

Sophie's Return in Joker: Folie A Deux Explained

Joker: Folie à Deux It reveals that Sophie survived the events of the first film when she was called to testify at Arthur's trial. Despite being a significant part of the first film, Sophie is only in this one scene in the sequel. It's also pretty important, though Sophie's testimony gives a deeper look at Arthur and his relationship with his motherThrough his conversations with Penny Fleck.

Joker 2019 Joaquin Phoenix Gotham Riot and Arkham Custom Image

Arthur's Big Confession at the End of Joker 2 Explained by Folie A Deux Director

Todd Phillips opens up about Joker: Folie a Deux's surprising courtroom twist and how Arthur's decision ties into the themes of the first film.

Sophie reveals how Penny Fleck really feels about her son. He was horrified that Arthur wanted to be a comedian, thinking that he wasn't actually funny and that what he told Arthur about being born to make people happy was just a lie he made up. His expression reveals what he thinks about Arthur throughout the events Jokerand confirms a deleted scene when he watched her on the Murray Franklin show. Sophie's role in the film is one of the turning points for Arthur to confess his crimes.